Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Book Review: Free Will, by Sam Harris




Sam Harris is among the "New Atheist" writers whose ranks include Daniel Dennett (Breaking the Spell), Richard Dawkins (The God Delusion), and the late Christopher Hitchens (God is Not Great). Harris' The End of Faith made a splash a couple years after the 9/11 attacks with its arguments against religion in general and Islam in particular: Harris holds faith to be fundamentally irrational, a bizarre and often destructive ritual in which reasoned cognition is suspended. He recently came out with a book on secular ethics titled The Moral Landscape (you can woefully attempt to look at the Harper's review here).

Yours truly was pretty heavily influence by Harris' End, though in the years since I was first caught in the headlights of his polemics, I've come to the opinion that he is very good at forcefully stating obvious truths in such a way that less obvious truths get obscured. For example, End begins with a short narrative of a suicide bombing. Harris describes the bomber, the bus he boards, his victims, and his family's reaction. At the end of this story, Harris points out that in spite of the fact that the narrative does not specify the bomber's religion, the reader is sure to presume him a Muslim. The rhetorical point (I took it) was that Islam really is a violent and dangerous religion, and everyone knows this already; it is only political correctness which keeps us from publicly saying so. In retrospect, I realize that Harris' story was the 21st century equivalent of race-baiting: the narrative didn't expose anything about Islam, but it did expose the way Americans think about Islam. Harris' deployment of an obvious truth ("You're imagining a suicide bomber as a Muslim") obscured subtler truths about e.g. the function of stereotypes in American culture.

The point of the preceding paragraph is just that yours truly is working some personal stuff out vis-a-vis Mr. Harris, who is a compelling and slippery fucker. (Harris also begins Free Will with another little story, this one about a multiple rape/murder--but hey, who can fault a champion of reason for habitually beginning his books with emotionally-charged anecdotes?)

In the tiny tract Free Will, Harris develops one of the claims he made in End: free will is not only false but, indeed, conceptually incoherent.

Free will is an illusion. Our wills are simply not of our own making. Thoughts and intentions emerge from background causes of which we are unaware and over which we exert no conscious control. We do not have the freedom we think we have.

Free will is actually more than an illusion (or less), in that it cannot be made conceptually coherent. Either our wills are determined by prior causes and we are not responsible for them, or they are the product of chance and we are not responsible for them.
(p. 5)

For Harris, saying that someone has free will is like talking about a square-circle. It just doesn't make sense. Our thoughts, "choices," identities, and behavior are all effected by natural causes, just like all other phenomena. There is no extra-causal soul or self which somehow exists outside of, and yet influences, the chains of cause-and-effect which makes up this world. We are caused objects. So how could there be free will? As Harris correctly points out, indeterminism is no help in this: even if, say, quantum indeterminacy means that determinism is false and every new moment is a product of chance, we're no closer to freedom than we were with determinism.

It's important to understand at the outset that Harris is not arguing against any sophisticated version of free will put forth by any philosopher, ever. He is opposed, rather, to commonsense notions of free will:

Our moral intuitions and sense of personal agency are anchored to a felt sense that we are the conscious source of our thoughts and actions. 
(p. 17)

Though Harris spends a good chunk of the book discussing compatibilism (the position that free will and causal-determinism are compatible, held by e.g. Benedict Spinoza and Daniel Dennett), he's not interested in refuting it. His purpose is to convince the reader that the so-called 'free will' which compatibilists are able to preserve is not really free will. It's a fake, like tofu chicken or a knockoff iPod. Harris uses the following comparison:

Imagine that a person claims to have no need to eat food of any kind--rather, he can live on light. From time to time, and Indian yogi will make such a boast, much to the merriment of skeptics. Needless to say, there is no reason to take such claims seriously, no matter how thin the yogi. However, a compatibilist like Dennett could come to the charlatan's defense: The man does live on light--we all do--because when you trace the origins of any food, you arrive at something that depends on photosynthesis. By eating beef, we consume the grass the cow ate, and the grass ate sunlight. So the yogi is no liar after all. But that's not the ability the yogi was advertising, and his actual claim remains dishonest (or delusional). This is the trouble with compatibilism. It solves the problem of "free will" by ignoring it.

Personally, I don't find this comparison very compelling. Dennett's compatibilism may or may not be adequate to the task of reconciling causal determination with human freedom, but it's much subtler than simply 'changing the conversation.' What's especially weird and alarm-bell-ringing about Harris' hostility toward compatibilism is that, later in the book, he begins to sound like a compatibilist. He sometimes writes of "choices" without any scare-quotes, and writes:

Therefore, while it is true to say that a person would have done otherwise if he had chosen to do otherwise, this does not deliver the kind of free will that most people seem to cherish...
(p. 35)

And later still:

Becoming sensitive to the background causes of one's thoughts and feelings can--paradoxically--allow for greater creative control over one's life...This understanding reveals you to be a biochemical puppet of course, but it also allows you to grab hold of one of your strings.
(p. 47)

What in the holy hell is going on here? I thought "Our wills are simply not of our own making"; now you're telling me that "a person would have done otherwise if he had chosen to do otherwise," i.e. he could have done otherwise? And you're telling me that I can gain "greater creative control over [my] life"? You're saying I'm a SELF-PUPPETEERING PUPPET?!?! How the hemorrhaging fuck am I NOT free, then?

In the spirit of cartoonish analogies, I'd like to offer my own: imagine someone said that, given the right equipment, they had the ability of flight--and indeed, with the help of an airplane, they do indeed appear to be flying! However, a non-compatibilist like Harris could criticize the so-called pilot: 'Sure, you seem to be flying, but upon closer investigation we find that what's really going on is just a series of normal physical events. For example, the movement of air across the wings creates upward lift. This is why you appear to be flying; but where is the flight in any of this?'

Harris, in other words, seems committed to rejecting any version of free will which can be coherently integrated into a cause-and-effect schema as not really free will. Intuitively-obvious free will is the only kind that counts. And, I mean, sure: Harris can decide that that's what he means when he talks about "free will," and he's quite correct to say that (that version of) free will is incoherent and non-existent. Correct, but in a trivial way: suppose I say that all maps are two-dimensional, and then you point out that globes are three-dimensional maps, and I say, "Well, they're not really maps. What I mean by 'map' is the commonsense notion of a map." Or as Nietzsche put it:

If I make up the definition of a mammal, and then, after inspecting a camel, declare "look, a mammal' I have indeed brought a truth to light in this way, but it is a truth of limited value.
(From On Truth and Lies in an Extra-Moral Sense)

There aren't any philosophers who take intuitively-obvious free will seriously. For heaven's sake, the entire discipline of psychology amounts to an investigation into the ways in the way's that people's wills are determined by other factors. And while it's true that most of us do use the notion of free will in our daily lives, and also true that a lot of good would come from our society paying more attention to the influences which determine people's behavior, it's not clear to me how writing a snarky, easy-reading philosophy tract is going to encourage anyone who isn't already a philosopher to think more carefully about freedom and causality. If this book is for philosophers, then it's like a fan-fic letter mailed to Jonathan Franzen; if it's for layfolk, then it's like a letter mailed to people who don't read their mail. In any event, why is Harris writing?

One last bone to pick: Harris is deeply inconsistent in his objects of attack. Throughout Free Will, Harris uses other intuitively-obvious notions which are also extremely tricky and problematic when you begin to think carefully about them, yet he concentrates his fire solely on free will and lets other concepts pass unscathed. For example, what do we mean when we talk about "cause?" Is it just reliable correlation? That's what statisticians mean, but that's definitely a watered-down version of what everyone else means by "cause." But what else is there, besides events happening together or not happening together? Or how about "identity": all of the problems Harris poses for free will are at least as problematic to any notion of "me" or "myself." Weirdly, Harris notes in End the problematic, illusory nature of selfhood, yet in Free Will he treats it as a non-issue. Or "object"? What is an "object"? Of course we speak of a physical world with stuff in it, but has anyone ever seen this physical world? Of course not! All we see are our impressions, which supposedly correspond to some 'real world.' And even supposing that there is a real world, what could it possible mean to say that there are different objects in it? It's all just one big whole; distinctions between this table and that tablecloth are illusory and incoherent...Etc.

My point is that there are lots and lots of tricky notions which become mottled and incoherent the moment we begin to think carefully about what they entail. This is not new. Pretty much all of our concepts are problematic. To say that free will has conceptual problems, as Harris does, is not to say that it doesn't exist; and a book concerned with evaluating free will seems obliged to give more consideration to philosophically robust versions of free will than End does.

We were the first store other than the publisher to list #Cypherpunks by Julian #Assange !!


Just listed at LWB: Cypherpunks: Freedom and the Future of the Internet - 19.99 USD http://bit.ly/WlIuqv
Unlike ·  · 

Got some gorgeous holiday/Christmas cards in stock!

Check em out! All from amazing counterculture-y artists. Got em straight from the museum of contemporary art in Los Angeles.



- Posted using my mobile book laboratory.

Two possibilities exist: either we are alone in the Universe or we are not. Both are equally terrifying. Arthur C. Clarke

Sunday, December 16, 2012

Every man is surrounded by a neighborhood of voluntary spies!




The author of Pride and Prejudice was born on this day in 1775.

There are so many to choose from!

One cannot be always laughing at a man without now and then stumbling on something witty.

Thursday, December 13, 2012

Human speech is like a cracked kettle on which we tap crude rhythms for bears to dance to, while we long to make music that will melt the stars. Gustave Flaubert

Happy belated birthday, Gustave!

The author of Madame Bovary was born two yesterdays ago in 1821.

Gustave Flaubert (French pronunciation: ​[ɡystav flobɛʁ]; December 12, 1821 – May 8, 1880) was a French writer who is counted among the greatest novelists in Western literature. He is known especially for his first published novel,Madame Bovary (1857), for his Correspondence, and for his scrupulous devotion to his art and style.

Don't be afraid to be confused. Try to remain permanently confused. Anything is possible. Stay open, forever, so open it hurts, and then open up some more, until the day you die, world without end, amen. George Saunders


George Saunders (born December 2, 1958) is a New York Times bestselling American writer of short stories, essays, novellas and children's books. His writing has appeared in The New Yorker, Harper's, McSweeney's and GQ, among other publications. He also contributed a weekly column, American Psyche, to the weekend magazine of The Guardian’s Saturday edition until October 2008.
A professor at Syracuse University, Saunders won the National Magazine Award for fiction in 1994, 1996, 2000, and 2004, and second prize in the O. Henry Awards in 1997. His first story collection, CivilWarLand in Bad Decline, was a finalist for the 1996 PEN/Hemingway Award. In 2006 Saunders received a MacArthur Fellowship. In 2006 he won the World Fantasy Award for his short story "CommComm".[1] His story collection In Persuasion Nation was a finalist for The Story Prize in 2007.

Daily Bleed for December 13th, A Radical Anarchist Daybook



thin line
Our Daily Bleed...


Let us have madness openly.
0 men Of my generation.
Let us follow
The footsteps of this slaughtered age:
See it trail across Time's dim land
Into the closed house of eternity
With the noise that dying has,
With the face that dead things wear –
nor ever say
We wanted more; we looked to find
An open door, an utter deed of love,
Transforming day's evil darkness;
but We found extended hell & fog Upon the earth,
& within the head
A rotting bog of lean huge graves.
— Kenneth Patchen, "Let Us Have Madness"




DECEMBER 13

KENNETH PATCHEN
"Naturalist of the Public Nightmare." Poet, artist, hellraiser.

Alternate Patron Saint: MARILYN BUCK
Militant American political prisoner, activist, translator, poet.

ST. LUCY'S DAY: In Scandinavia, a day for boisterous winter fun, first sleigh rides of the season. Singing must be loud enough to frighten off the gnomes.
Loaves of ceremonial bread are baked in shape of cats (echo of pre-Christian sacrifices to earth powers) formerly a procession followed a cow with candles on her horns.
In Hungary, witches ride broomsticks & boys & girls pull all the pranks they can get away with.

Acatl symbol

Aztec Calendar: ACATL DAY.
Acatl is the scepter of authority which is, paradoxically, hollow. Arrows of fate fall from the sky like lightning bolts.
Good day to seek justice, bad day to act against others.



1509 -- England: The first book in Roman type in Britain is published, Ship of Fools.
[Source: Robert Braunwart] [Hereafter noted with symbol: Source=Robert Braunwart]


1577 -- Francis Drake leaves England on second-ever voyage round-the-world voyage.


Taz
1652 -- Dutch navigator Abel Tasman discovers the south Pacific island group later known as New Zealand. While attempting to land, several of Tasman's crew are killed by warriors from the native Maori people, who interpret the European's exchange of trumpet signals as a prelude to battle. & right they were.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporary_Autonomous_Zone
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taz_Express



1784 -- Samuel Johnson, 75, dies in pious resignation.


1795 -- Source=Robert Braunwart According to SF author Philip Jose Farmer, a meteor impacts near Wold Newton, Yorks — beginning of the Wayne Wold Newton families. [The family tree what Fig Newtons come from??] 



Burning books
1797 -- Lyric poet, satirist, rebel Heinrich Heine lives, Dusseldorf, Germany. He prophesies:
"Wherever they burn books, they will also, in the end burn human beings."
HEINRICH HEINE 1997 SAINT
Tragic poet of the "mattress grave," revolutionist, comrade.

http://www.kirjasto.sci.fi/hheine.htm


1823 -- William W. How, Anglican clergyman, lives. Shunning higher ecclesiastical positions, he worked among the poor in East London. Wrote 50 hymns; "For All the Saints" remains one of his most popular.


1824 -- Hawaiia: Kapiolani defies Pele & lives. High Chiefess Queen Kapiolani visits Kilauea & defies the volcano goddess Pele by descending into the crater.
Hawaiian legends tell that eruptions were caused by Pele, the beautiful but tempestuous Goddess of Volcanoes, during her frequent moments of anger. Pele was both revered & feared; her immense power & many adventures figured prominently in ancient Hawaiian songs & chants. She could cause earthquakes by stamping her feet & volcanic eruptions & fiery devastation by digging with the Pa'oe, her magic stick. An oft-told legend describes the long & bitter quarrel between Pele & her older sister Namakaokahai that led to the creation of the chain of volcanoes that form the islands.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Not knowing when the dawn will come I open every door. Emily Dickinson



The American poet was born on this day in 1830.

From Wikipedia: Emily Elizabeth Dickinson (December 10, 1830 – May 15, 1886) was an American poet. Born in Amherst, Massachusetts, to a successful family with strong community ties, she lived a mostly introverted and reclusive life. After she studied at the Amherst Academy for seven years in her youth, she spent a short time at Mount Holyoke Female Seminary before returning to her family's house in Amherst. Thought of as an eccentric by the locals, she became known for her penchant for white clothing and her reluctance to greet guests or, later in life, even leave her room. Most of her friendships were therefore carried out by correspondence.
While Dickinson was a prolific private poet, fewer than a dozen of her nearly eighteen hundred poems were published during her lifetime.[2] The work that was published during her lifetime was usually altered significantly by the publishers to fit the conventional poetic rules of the time. Dickinson's poems are unique for the era in which she wrote; they contain short lines, typically lack titles, and often use slant rhyme as well as unconventional capitalization and punctuation.[3]Many of her poems deal with themes of death and immortality, two recurring topics in letters to her friends.
Although most of her acquaintances were probably aware of Dickinson's writing, it was not until after her death in 1886—when Lavinia, Emily's younger sister, discovered her cache of poems—that the breadth of Dickinson's work became apparent. Her first collection of poetry was published in 1890 by personal acquaintances Thomas Wentworth Higginsonand Mabel Loomis Todd, both of whom heavily edited the content. A complete and mostly unaltered collection of her poetry became available for the first time in 1955 when The Poems of Emily Dickinson was published by scholar Thomas H. Johnson. Despite unfavorable reviews and skepticism of her literary prowess during the late 19th and early 20th century, critics now consider Dickinson to be a major American poet.[4]

Sunday, December 09, 2012

Daily Bleed for December 9th, A Radical Anarchist Daybook



Cat Has Had the Time of His Life
thin line
Our Daily Bleed...


"Any person who has had the following dream. You are in a subway station of a major city. At the far end you see a coffee machine. You put in two coins. The Holy Grail drops down. Then blood pours into the chalice."

"The person who borrowed my Martin Beck thriller, read it in a sauna which melted the glue off the spine so the pages drifted to the floor, stapled them together & returned the book, thinking I wouldn't notice."
      — Michael Ondaatje, Elimination Dance



DECEMBER 9

PYOTR KROPOTKIN
"The Red Prince," Russian anarchist theorist.

http://recollectionbooks.com/bleed/Encyclopedia/KropotkinPeter.htm

Patzcuaro, Mexico: FIESTA OF THE MOTHER OF HEALTH. Fishermens' Fiesta, with much dancing, clowning & fireworks.

& this reminder, lest things are going too well in your life, this is:
NATIONAL INDIGESTION SEASON.
INTERNATIONAL (GOVERNMENT) ANTI-CORRUPTION DAY. Yup.




Joe Camel
656 -- Source=Robert Braunwart 'Ali's forces win the Battle of the Camel
in the first Muslim civil war.
Float like a butterfly sting like a bee!




1292 -- Sa'di, great Persian poet (Orchard; Rose Garden) dies.


1460 -- Madcap medieval rhymester John Skelton lives.
Once, when being upbraided by Cardinal Wolsey he quipped,
"I pray, your grace, to let me lie down & wallow,
for I can kneel no longer."

Source: [Calendar Riots]


1531 -- México: Virgin of Guadalupe appears to an Indian boy.


1570 -- Geuzen under Herman de Ruyter occupies Loevestein.



1608 -- British "Paradise Lost": epic writer John Milton lives, Bread Street, Cheapside, London. The "Prince of Poets" also wrote First Defense of the English People, justifying the execution of Charles I.

On his birthday in 1631 he wrote: "How soon hath Time, the subtle thief of youth,/ Stoltn on his wing my three-and-twentieth year!"

After completing his First Defense of the English People, he went blind at 43. Alfred, Lord Tennyson later apostrophizes the author of Paradise Lost: "O mighty-mouth'd inventor of harmonies, /O skill'd to sing of Time or Eternity,/God-gifted organ-voice of England, / Milton, a name to resound for ages."
http://www.literature.org/authors/milton-john/paradise-lost/
http://johnmilton.org/
http://www.kirjasto.sci.fi/jmilton.htm


1640 -- New Old World: Settler Hugh Bewitt is banished from colony of Massachusetts when he declares himself to be free of original sin. Much like the Old World.


1777 -- England: Reverend Benjamin Russen executed at Tyburn, for rape.


1801 -- German writer Johann Gottfried Seume starts his tour on foot from Saxony, crosses the Alps & walks through Italy to Sicily. His return trip takes him through Switzerland & even to Paris. The whole trip takes only eight months & results in Spaziergang nach Syrakus im Jahre (A Stroll to Syracuse).



1828 -- Joseph Dietzgen, socialist, lives, near Cologne, Germany. Important socialist theorist whose writings exerted considerable influence on the workers' movement. Wrote The Nature of Human Brain-Work (1869).

"While the anarchists may have mad & brainless individuals in their ranks, the socialists have an abundance of cowards. For this reason I care as much for one as the other."
Piotr Kropotkin
1842 -- Russia: Prince Peter Kropotkin, important geographer & anarchist communist, lives, Moscow. "The prince who became a revolutionist."

PYOTR KROPOTKIN
Russian revolutionist, anarchist, landmark geographer.
The Prince who shunned material wealth.
     
In the Encyclopedia Britannica (for which he wrote the "anarchy" definition in the famed 11th edition) Kropotkin describes himself:
"Although he achieved renown in a number of different fields, ranging from geography & zoology to sociology & history, he shunned material success for the life of a revolutionist."


Fat rabbit in rocking chair
1848 -- Folklorist Joel Chandler Harris lives, Putnam County, Georgia. Discovers Tar Baby syndrome. Creator of Uncle Remus & Brer Rabbit.
http://xroads.virginia.edu/~UG97/remus/contents.html



1854 -- Alfred Tennyson's The Charge of the Light Brigade published six weeks after the Battle of Balaclava.


1868 -- anarchist diamond dingbatItaly: Paolo Lega lives (1868-??). In 1894 the young anarchist attempts to shoot Francesco Crispi, président du conseil Italien. The bullet lodged in Crispi's car rather than Crispi; Lega was arrested & did 20-years in prison for his poor aim.
Source: Ephéméride anarchiste


1869 -- US: Knights of Labor founded in Philadelphia, as a secret society open to all members of the producing classes except "parasites" including stockbrokers, gamblers, & lawyers. Founded by Uriah Stevens & five other garment workers. Stevens, a tailor who once studied for the Baptist ministry, leads the order.
http://www.history.umd.edu/Gompers/chron1.htm


1889 -- Source=Robert Braunwart US: The Press expedition arrives in Port Angeles to begin exploring the Olympic Mountains (Washington State).

State of the United States (2011)

* 44 Million Americans on food stamps, including 1 out of 4 children

* # of low income jobs now = 41% of all jobs in U.S.

* 50 million people have no health insurance

* 5.5 million unemployed receive no unemployment

* The percentage of millionaires in Congress is 50x higher than the percentage of millionaires in the general population

* Student Loan Debt = $1 Trillion Dollars, having now surpassed U.S. credit card debt

* Cost of college education is now 900% more than it was in 1978

Thanks mom, and U.S. Business Insider.

Here's a nice piece from U.S. BI detailing real facts about our economic 'recovery'. Which concludes that... drum roll...  Picture from Wikipedia's page on Economic Inequality

Private-sector job growth under Barack Obama has been just as good if not better than it was under George Bush.

For books are not absolutely dead things, but do contain a potency of life in them to be as active as that soul was whose progeny they are; nay, they do preserve as in a vial the purest efficacy and extraction of that living intellect that bred them. John Milton

The author of Paradise Lost was born on this day in 1608.

From Wikipedia: 


John Milton (9 December 1608 – 8 November 1674) was an English poet, polemicist, a scholarly man of letters, and a civil servant for the Commonwealth of England under Oliver Cromwell. He wrote at a time of religious flux and political upheaval, and is best known for his epic poem Paradise Lost.
Milton's poetry and prose reflect deep personal convictions, a passion for freedom and self-determination, and the urgent issues and political turbulence of his day. Writing in English, Latin, and Italian, he achieved international renown within his lifetime, and his celebrated Areopagitica, (written in condemnation of pre-publication censorship) is among history's most influential and impassioned defenses of free speech and freedom of the press.
William Hayley's 1796 biography called him the "greatest English author",[1] and he remains generally regarded "as one of the preeminent writers in the English language";[2] though critical reception has oscillated in the centuries since his death (often on account of his republicanism). Samuel Johnson praised Paradise Lost as "a poem which...with respect to design may claim the first place, and with respect to performance, the second, among the productions of the human mind," though Johnson (a Tory and recipient of royal patronage) described Milton's politics as those of an"acrimonious and surly republican".
Because of his republicanism, Milton has been the subject of centuries of British partisanship (a "nonconformist" biography by John Toland, a hostile account by Anthony à Wood, etc.).

Saturday, December 08, 2012

Not one of your pertinent ancestors was squashed, devoured, drowned, starved, stranded, stuck fast, untimely wounded, or otherwise deflected from its life's quest of delivering a tiny charge of genetic material to the right partner at the right moment in order to perpetuate the only possible sequence of hereditary combinations that could result -- eventually, astoundingly, and all too briefly -- in you. Bill Bryson

The author of A Short History of Nearly Everything was born on this day in 1951.

From Wikipedia:


William McGuire "Bill" Bryson, OBE, (born December 8, 1951) is a best-selling American author of humorous books on travel, as well as books on the English language and on science. Born an American, he was a resident of Britain for most of his adult life before returning to the US in 1995. In 2003 Bryson moved back to Britain, living in the old rectory of Wramplingham, Norfolk, and was appointed Chancellor of Durham University.
Bryson shot to prominence in the United Kingdom with the publication of Notes From A Small Island (1995), an exploration of Britain, for which he made an accompanying television series. He received widespread recognition again with the publication of A Short History of Nearly Everything (2003), which popularised scientific questions for a general audience.

Thanks to Goodreads for their e-mail service of daily quotes.

Contradict yourself. In order to live, you must remain broken up. Wyndham Lewis



Friday, December 07, 2012

The world is little, people are little, human life is little. There is only one big thing — desire. Willa Cather


The author of My Ántonia was born on this day in 1873.

From Wikipedia: Willa Sibert Cather (December 7, 1873[1] – April 24, 1947) was an American author who achieved recognition for her novels of frontier life on the Great Plains, in works such as O Pioneers!, My Ántonia, and The Song of the Lark. In 1923 she was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for One of Ours (1922), a novel set during World War I. Cather grew up inNebraska and graduated from the University of Nebraska. She lived and worked in Pittsburgh for ten years, then at the age of 33 she moved to New York, where she lived for the rest of her life.

Perhaps all the dragons in our lives are princesses who are only waiting to see us act, just once, with beauty and courage. Perhaps everything that frightens us is, in its deepest essence, something helpless that wants our love. Rainer Maria Rilke



The author of Letters to a Young Poet was born last Tuesday in 1875.

Happy belated birthday Rilke!

Thursday, December 06, 2012

Grammar is a piano I play by ear. Joan Didion



The author of The Year of Magical Thinking was born yesterday in 1934.

Happy belated birthday Joan!

Wednesday, December 05, 2012

Daily Bleed for December 5th, a Radical Anarchist Daybook


Our Daily Bleed...

Things To Do Today:
Make new friends —
(go to a poetry recital
& ask why each poem doesn't rhyme).



George Brecht
DECEMBER 5
GEORGE BRECHT

American Fluxus artist, chemist, vanguard composer.



Ancient Rome: FESTIVAL OF FAUNUS. Feasting & merrymaking.

Belgium: ST. NICHOLAS' EVE. Black Peter, Nick's Moorish servant, drops down the chimney with gifts for the children.


A commodity has value ... A gift has worth.

— Lewis Hyde





1349 -- Jews are massacred at Nuremberg in Black death riots.


1484 -- Source=Robert Braunwart The pope establishes severe penalties against German witches & magicians; over the next 300 years perhaps 200,000 accused witches are executed. It's a mean nasty ugly job, but somebody has to do it...& who better but the Catholic Church?


1770 -- Six of the British troops involved in the Boston Massacre found innocent, largely due to defense attorney John Adams' intimation that Crispus Attucks, America's first black hero, may have caused "the dreadful carnage of that night" with his "mad behavior...at the head of...[a] rabble of Negroes..."


1784 -- Phillis Wheatley dies, aged about 31 years, Boston. First black woman poet &, after Anne Bradstreet, only the second woman poet of note in the US. The 39 poems inPoems on Various Subjects, Religious & Moral, published in 1773 in England under the sponsorship of the Countess of Huntingdon, help spread her reputation in Europe as well as in America.


Saturday, December 01, 2012

Sorrow is how we learn to love. Your heart isn't breaking. It hurts because it's getting larger. The larger it gets, the more love it holds. Rita Mae Brown

Rita Mae Brown (born November 28, 1944) is an American writer. She is best known for her first novel Rubyfruit Jungle. Published in 1973, it dealt with lesbian themes in an explicit manner unusual for the time. Brown is also a mystery writer and screenwriter.

That's a young Miss Brown on the right in the Lavender Menace shirt.

Reining in Obama and His Drones by Ralph Nader


Barack Obama, former president of the Harvard Law Review and a constitutional law lecturer, should go back and review his coursework. He seems to have declined to comport his presidency to the rule of law.

Let’s focus here on his major expansion of drone warfare in defiance of international law, statutory law and the Constitution. Obama’s drones roam over multiple nations of Asia and Africa and target suspects, both known and unknown, whom the president, in his unbridled discretion, wants to evaporate for the cause of national security.

More than 2,500 people have been killed by Obama’s drones, many of them civilians and bystanders, including American citizens, irrespective of the absence of any “imminent threat” to the United States.

As Justin Elliott of ProPublica wrote: “Under Obama…only 13 percent (of those killed) could be considered militant leaders - either of the Pakistani Taliban, the Afghan Taliban, or Al Qaeda.” The remaining fatalities, apart from many innocent civilians, including children, were people oppressed by their own harsh regimes or dominated by U.S. occupation of their country. Aside from human rights and the laws of war, this distinction between civilian and combatant matters because it shows that Obama’s drones are becoming what Elliott calls “a counterinsurgency air force” for our collaborative regimes.

The “kill lists”  are the work of Obama and his advisors, led by John O. Brennan, and come straight from the White House, according to The New York Times.  Apparently, the president spends a good deal of time being prosecutor, judge, jury, executioner and concealer. But he does so quietly; this is no dramatic “thumbs-down” emperor.

Mr. Brennan spoke at Harvard Law School about a year ago and told a remarkably blasé audience that what he and the president were doing was perfectly legal under the law of self-defense. Self-defense that is defined, of course, by the president.

It appears from recent statements on The Daily Show that President Obama does not share the certitude boldly displayed by Mr. Brennan. On October 18, President Obama told John Stewart, and his audience, that “one of the things we’ve got to do is put a legal architecture in place, and we need Congressional help in order to do that, to make sure that not only am I reined in but any president is reined in terms of some of the decisions that we’re making.”

So in the absence of “a legal architecture” of accountability, do presidents knock off whomever they want to target (along with bystanders or family members), whether or not the targeted person is actually plotting an attack against the United States? It seems that way, in spite of what is already in place legally, called the Constitution, separation of powers and due process of law. What more legal architecture does Mr. Obama need?

Obviously what he wants is a self-contained, permanent “Office of Presidential Predator Drone Assassinations” in the White House, to use, author, scholar and litigator Bruce Fein’s nomenclature. According to The New York Times, President Obama wants “ explicit rules for targeted killing…. So that a new president would inherit clear standards and procedures.” Mr. Fein notes that “clear standards and procedures without accountability to the judiciary, Congress, or the American people” undermine the rule of law and our democracy.

Indeed, the whole deliberation process inside the Obama administration has been kept secret, a continuing process of morbid over-classification that even today contains secret internal legal opinions on targeted killings. The government refuses even to acknowledge that a drone air force operates over Pakistan - a fact that everybody knows including the hundreds of injured and displaced Pakistanis. This drone air force uses, what The New York Times called, “signature strikes against groups of suspected, unknown militants.”

Predictably, these strikes are constantly terrorizing thousands of families who fear a strike anytime day or night, and are causing a blowback that is expanding the number of Al Qaeda sympathizers and affiliates from Pakistan to Yemen. “Signature strikes,” according to the Times, “have prompted the greatest conflict inside the Obama administration.” Former CIA director under George W. Bush, Michael V. Hayden has publically questioned whether the expansion in the use of drones is counterproductive and creating more enemies and the desire for more revenge against the U.S.

Critics point out how many times in the past that departments and agencies have put forth misleading or false intelligence, from the Vietnam War to the arguments for invading Iraq, or have missed what they should have predicted such as the fall of the Soviet Union. This legacy of errors and duplicity should restrain presidents who execute, by ordering drone operators to push buttons that target people thousands of miles away, based on secret, so-called intelligence.

Mr. Obama wants, in Mr. Fein’s view, to have “his secret and unaccountable predator drone assassinations become permanent fixtures of the nation’s national security complex.” Were Obama to remember his constitutional law, such actions would have to be constitutionally authorized by Congress and subject to judicial review.

With his Attorney General Eric Holder maintaining that there is sufficient due process entirely inside the Executive Branch and without Congressional oversight or judicial review, don’t bet on anything more than a more secret, violent, imperial presidency that shreds the Constitution’s separation of powers and checks and balances.

And don’t bet that other countries of similar invasive bent won’t remember this green-light on illegal unilateralism when they catch up with our drone capabilities.

Drew's Videotape

Drew discovered the videotape when he was eight years old. Banished to the downstairs by his mother and admonished to "Find something to occupy yourself," he pawed through the cardboard box of VHS cassettes in search of age-appropriate material. Beneath The Birdcage and Lethal Weapon 2 he came across an unmarked cassette, its black casing scratched but intact.

He loaded it into the VCR, adjusted the channel, and pressed play. The screen showed a woman peering out at him--or rather into a video camera like those his mother used on vacations, Drew quickly amended. "Hello?" said the woman. She was fair-skinned and plump with red, shoulder length hair. She wore a blue tank top and jeans. "I don't know if this will work. Can you hear me?"

Drew returned to the box of cassettes, determined to unearth a Sesame Street or Muppets recording. "But if you can, please listen. I need your help. I think you can help me, I don't know. Listen. I want to try an experiment." Drew's eye lit upon a checkered cover: Dr. Blockhead and Friends. He retrieved it from the pile of movies and studied the cover, ambivalent. "I want you to take this tape and record over it," said the woman. "Record yourself speaking. Say that you saw me: describe the video that you're watching right now." Drew slid the cover from the cassette and turned toward the VCR. "Then wait for a week and then watch this tape again. I know this sounds crazy, but...Listen. My name is Drew. " Drew paused at the sound of his name. "Drew Stein. I don't have any way to convince you to do this, but please, please--" The television screen went blue as the tape reached its end.

Drew hesitated, the Dr. Blockhead tape held before him. He looked at it, then at the blue television. He put the Dr. Blockhead tape on the floor, ejected the unlabeled tape, and went to the closet beside the stairs. Inside he found a massive suitcase which housed his mother's videocamera, before which he again paused. Then he recalled her imperative. Drew reasoned that while damaging the exotic camera would surely inspire a swift vengence, he could, in that sad instance, take refuge in the vagueness of "occupy yourself." Thus prepared, he tucked the tape under his armpit and dragged the suitcase into the living room.

Several minutes later, Drew had successfully plugged the camera into a wall socket, removed the lens cover, inserted the unlabeled tape, and (after much trial and error) pressed the button with the red circle which signified "record."

"Hello. My name is also Drew. I watched a tape with a lady on it who said her name was Drew Stein. She asked me to record myself saying this, so, here I am. Thank you."

Drew played the tape on the VCR to be sure that he had properly recorded himself. He was fascinated by what he saw: so tiny, such a high voice, such big hair. Ill at ease, he ejected the blank tape and shoved it to the bottom of the cardboard case, covering it with copies of his mother's exercise videos. He carefully returned the video recorder to its case and dragged the case back into the closet. Then he went to the kitchen and drank some milk.

Two years later, Drew again came across the tape, engaged in a similar search for novel entertainment. Having exhausted his penchant for Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2, he popped the mystery tape into the VCR, sat down, and hit play.

"Drew! Oh, Drew, you saw it! Thank you so much for trying this, I know how strange it it is. Listen, I got your message. You said," Drew Stein said, and then she repeated his two year old statement. "This works! Can you believe it?"

Ten-year old Drew was unable to answer that question. The image of the woman, and her quotation of his own words, had jogged his memory enough that he now vividly recalled that day, two years prior, when he'd been bored enough to drag out the video camera. His mouth hung loose, his eyes narrowed, and he leaned forward on the couch.

"Drew!" Drew Stein said. "It works!"