Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Daily Bleed for Christmas Day, A Radical Anarchist Daybook


Cat Has Had the Time of His Life
thin line

Our Daily Bleed...


Patchen & Mingus; source jargonbooks.com

What has been separated from the mother,
Must again be joined; for we were born of spirit,
& to spirit all mortal things return,
As it is necessary in the method of the earth.
So sings the parable of singleness.
My comforter does not conceal his face;
I have seen appearances that were not marshalled
By sleep.
— Kenneth Patchen, excerpt, "The Cloth of the Tempest"
http://www.connectotel.com/patchen/




DECEMBER 25


JESUS OF NAZARETH 


Persecuted leader of an underground liberation movement, 

jubilator, social radical, martyr, son of a God.



CHRISTIAN CHRISTMAS. Santa Claus — Capitalist Tool or Red Menace? 



BIRTH DAY OF MITHRAS. Persian symbol of the ever-returning sun, celebrated at midwinter & embodying the triumph of light over darkness. He is recalled in blazing fires & puddings. 


Cipactli 


Aztec calendar: Today is CIPACTLI (Crocodile). Protector of the day is Tonacatecuhtli, Lord of Nurturance, the primordial god of creation & fertility. Cipactli is an auspicious day, signifying advancement & honor. It depicts energy & work, rewards & recognition. A good day for beginnings. 


BIRTH DAY of the sun god ATTIS, at Phrygia, now in Turkey. 


Congo: CHILDREN'S DAY. 


CELEBRATE OUR MONKEYS ANCESTORS DAY.



Pope surrounded with bare breasts


0 -- Symbolic beginning of the destruction of the world in the name of Jesus Christ & Western Civilization. The birthday of the 'christ-god' only falls in step with the 25th in 354CE & only becomes important enough to merit the name 'Christmas' in 1132CE.

JESUS 1997 PATRON SAINT 

Persecuted leader of an underground liberation movement, Jubilator, social radical, martyr.

Apocryphal birth of Jesus Christ, in an obscure village, child of a peasant woman. Worked in a carpenter shop until 30. Then for three years an unemployed itinerant preacher. Never wrote a book, never held office, had a family or owned a house. Didn't go to college, had no credentials. Never visited a big city nor traveled more than 200 miles from his birthplace. Did none of the things one usually associates with greatness. 


He was 33 when the tide of public opinion turned against him & his pals ditched him. Turned over to his enemies, went through the mockery of a trial. He was nailed to a cross between two thieves. While dying, his executioners gambled for his clothing, his only property. Buried in a borrowed grave through the pity of a friend. 

Fully fits the description of a bum, a vagrant, a ne'er do well.

God rest ye Bleeders/Bibliomaniacs/Moocheads, let nothing you dismay
Remember there's no evidence there was a Christmas day.
When Christ was born just is not known, no matter what they say,
Glad tidings of reason & fact, reason & fact,
Glad tidings of reason & fact. 


There was no star of Bethlehem, there was no angel song,
There could have been no wise men, for the journey was too long,
The stories in the Bible are historically wrong,
Glad tidings of reason & fact, reason & fact,
Glad tidings of reason & fact. 



Much of our Christmas custom comes from Persia & from Greece,
From solstice celebrations of the ancient Middle East,
Our so-called Christmas holiday is but a pagan feast,
Glad tidings of reason & fact, reason & fact,
Glad tidings of reason & fact. 



(this ran in sci.archaeology in 1994, with a credit to "author unknown")


When Christ was born just is not known, no matter what they say... 4 BC sometime in June or July.

Don't trust me.

— John


How certain are you, LimeyBeing?

— Dan


That was the consensus in the Groves of Academe last I heard. 

— John


The beauty of this multicultural system, to me, resides in its total lack of allegiance to any one emic reality, & in its conditioning the users to think in comparative realities. Thus, to most Americans, December 25 means Christ-mass & even the atheists feel dragged into the Reality Grid of the Romish cult. But on my multiple calendar system, the same date appears in many guises — as 25 Zeus, 72 p.s.U. or as 25 December Anno XC or as 25 Sable 122 E.P. or as 5 Nivose, 203, or as 22 Rajab, 1373 A.H. or as 67 International Relations, 3178 y.C., or as the 22nd day of the 11th month, 4692, or as 11 Dog, 5106, , or as 23 Teves 5755 A.M., or as 67 Realpolitik, 5994 A.L. You have a wide choice of what to celebrate. Why not celebrate all of them? But don't go driving afterwards. 


— Robert Anton Wilson 

Sun God Lodge



Although Christians celebrate December 25 as the birthday of Christ, no one in the first two Christian centuries had any knowledge of the exact day or year in which he was born. Most Christians were more interested with the story of his death. However, early in the fourth-century, Church fathers, who were concerned about the popularity of Mithraism, designated December 25th, the traditional birthday of the sun god Mithras, as Christ's official birth date. The celebration of the birth of Christ also took over the pagan winter solstice holiday, which like the birthday of Mithras, fell in late December. From thereon, December 25th was to be observed at a holy mass, or "Christ's Mass." 


336 -- First recorded celebration of Christmas on December 25 occurs in Rome. 
video




1611 -- Merry Christmas?: 

Settlers under Sir Thomas Dale destroy Apamatuks village on the lower Appomattox River in Virginia; settlers erect townsite of Bermuda Hundred on the site.
Analytical-minded precursors of Natural Scientists, Economists & Anthropologists, Christ-bearer & his accomplices find things, objects, which they automatically categorize as obstacles or as potential instruments...The names are not only projections. They are also definitions. Once defined, the objects can be manipulated. Savages are potential instruments; they can be put to work. Cannibals are obstacles; they have to be liquidated.

Thus the Blessed Isles are converted into a Leviathanic wilderness or, in the other language, the Wilderness is converted into a part of Christian Civilization.

       — Fredy Perlman, Against His-story, Against Leviathan!



1621 -- New Old World: No More "Age of Empires"?: Massachusetts halts all sinful game-playing, confiscates toys. Sorry, No more Sega Dreamcaster. No more Sony Playstation. Toy R Us lays off thousands. Toys.com sees shares fall from $86 to two-bits.




1642 -- Isaac Newton, astronomer/mathematician, author of Principia, lives, Woolsthorpe, Lincolnshire.




1647 -- England: "Multitude's Idle Day": in opposition to miserable puritanism & the increasing centralisation of authority, a Canterbury crowd close down all the shops that have obeyed the order to open for Christmas. They proceed to serve free drinks for all, pelt the Presbyterian minister with shit, & open the city gaol. 



When the mayor is vanquished & his officers seen off, the crowd produces footballs & some billeted republican soldiers desert & join in the fun. 




1721 -- William Collins, pre-Romantic poet considered one of the finest English lyric poets of the 18th century, lives, Chichester, Sussex. His "Ode on the Popular Superstitions of the Highlands of Scotland" (1749) anticipates many of the attitudes & interests of the Romantic poets.




1771 -- Dorothy Wordsworth, sister & caretaker to William, lives, Cockermouth, Cumberland. Her own writings, Alfoxden Journal & Grasmere Journals are appreciated as much for the imaginative power of their description of nature, perfection of style, & revelation of a personality of unusual quality as they are for the light they throw on her brother.

"I should detest the idea of setting myself up as an author."





1776 -- New Old World: During the American War for Independence, General George Washington violates the traditional Christmas truce, leading a secret crossing of the Delaware River with 5,400 troops, hoping to surprise a Hessian force celebrating Christmas at their winter quarters in Trenton, New Jersey.

The unconventional attack comes after months of defeats for Washington's army, & the loss of New York City & other strategic points in the state. At about 11 at night on Christmas, his army begins crossing the half-frozen river at three locations. The 2,400 soldiers brave the freezing temperature, rain, & icy river, & reach the New Jersey side of the Delaware before dawn. The other two divisions (some 3,000 men & important artillery) fail to reach the meeting point by the time of the attack. At approximately 8am of December 26, his remaining force, separated into two columns, reaches the outskirts of Trenton & descends on the unsuspecting Hessians. Trenton's 1,400 Hessian defenders are groggy from the previous evening's festivities &, after months of decisive British victories throughout New York, underestimate the Patriot threat.



(Oh, & did we mention his famed dentures weren't made of wood?) 



1796 -- Writer Fernán Caballero (Cecilia Francisca Josefa de Arrom) lives.




1837 -- US: Beloved & Respected Comrade Leader Col. Zachary Taylor, commanding 1,100 troops, attacks Seminole tribe on north shore of Lake Okeechobee, Florida. 170 troops & 14 Seminoles killed.




1868 -- US: Despite bitter opposition, Beloved & Respected Comrade Leader President Andy Johnson grants unconditional pardon to all persons involved in the Southern rebellion (the Civil War).




1870 -- Germany: Rosa Luxembourg's 'official' birthday — see 5 March. 




1875 -- Jessie Wallace Hughan, founder of War Resisters League (WRL), lives.

"A war is not like an earthquake or a tornado — it is an act of men & women. Wars will cease when men refuse to fight — & women refuse to approve. Do not allow people to lead you to think for a moment that war is a necessary institution."




1887 -- Overwhelmed by poverty, ideological confusion, grief at his grandmother's death, & ineligibility as a peasant to enter the Imperial Kazan University, Maxim Gorky attempts suicide at 18.




1892 -- Rebecca West lives. English journalist, novelist, critic. Her companion for 10 years was H. G. Wells. Their son Anthony is also a noted author & critic. West is perhaps best known for her reports on the Nürnberg trials (1945-46). 



Film Poster, Treasure of the Sierra Madre


1899 -- Film tough-guy Humphrey Bogart lives again. Stars in John Huston's film of anarchist B. Traven's novel, Treasure of the Sierra Madre & other excellent films such as The African Queen, Casablanca, The Big Sleep & The Maltese Falcon. Humphrey Bogart was an expert chess player & played for stakes.






1902 -- England: Dec 25/26, founding Congress of the Federation of the Anarchist Groups of Yiddish language of the United Kingdom & Paris, held in London.

A federation of Jewish anarchist groups was formed in 1902, the circulation of the papers & other publications increased, & a thriving social club was opened in Jubilee Street in East London in 1906. 


Rudolf Rocker was the most influential figure in the movement...




?


1903 -- Radical illustrator Raphael Soyer, lives — the quintessence of weary wistfulness.







1910 -- Dynamite Xmas?: Dynamite bomb destroys a portion of the Llewellyn Ironworks in Los Angeles, where a bitter strike is in progress. 





1914 -- All Quiet on the Western Front?: Traitors, cowards & would-be draft dodgers & riff-raff celebrate Christmas in no mans land. 



Just after midnight on Christmas morning, the majority of German troops engaged in WWI cease firing guns & artillery, & commence to sing Christmas carols.

At certain points along the Eastern & Western fronts, the soldiers of Russia, France, & Britain even hear brass bands joining the Germans in their joyous singing. At the first light of dawn, many of the German soldiers emerge from their trenches & approach the Allied lines across no man's land, calling out "Merry Christmas" in their enemies' native tongues. At first the Allied soldiers suspect it to be a trick, but soon climb out of their trenches & shake hands with the German soldiers. The men exchange presents of cigarettes & plum puddings & sing carols & songs & the Christmas Truce lasts a few days.
Documentation is fragmentary since it was contrary to direct orders & the legal penalty for such fraternizing with the enemy was death! But even in this brutal war, peace was found on this day by ignoring political & military authority.
All quiet on the Western Front, nobody saw

A youth asleep in the foreign soil, planted by the war
Feel the pulse of human blood pouring forth
See the stems of Europe bend under force 

All quiet
All quiet
All quiet on the Western Front 



— Music by Elton John, Lyrics by Bernie Taupin






1919 -- 
anarchist diamond; anarquista
Chile: Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) forms administration. 







1923 -- ToysRUs?: 57-year-old author/socialist H. G. Wells spends Christmas morning playing with his new toy soldiers. 




1924 -- Rod Serling lives in the Night Gallery, Twilight Zone, Binghampton, NY.




1925 -- Carlos Castaneda lives. Anthropologist & author of number of book describing the teachings of Don Juan, a Yaqui sorcerer & shaman. Castaneda kept himself out of the public eye & there has been much debate as to whether or not his books are documented fact or entirely fiction.




1926 -- Nicaragua:



The prostitutes of Puerto Cabezas help Augusto C. Sandino obtain arms & ammunition.

Nicaragua — a country condemned to produce cheap desserts — keeps ruining the digestion of its customers. In vain the invaders seek victory through hunger, by burning huts & crops.

Families are forced to flee & wander in the mountains. The campesinos believe Sandino knows how to lure the rainbow to him; & as it comes it shrinks until he can pick it up with just two fingers.


Tuesday, December 25, 2012

Book Review: John Dies at the End, by David Wong


John Dies at the End (JDatE) is a sort of sprawling, ill- or un-designed shantytown of clever ideas held together by duct tape and enthusiasm. The cover advertises that it's like Steven King + Douglas Adams, and this is pretty much accurate. If that sounds like your cup of tea, then by all means, read this novel. If you want your fiction to be more than a series of clever punch-lines within a drywall-hollow "story," then I'd suggest Ready Player One instead (review pending).

Don't get me wrong: author and protagonist David Wong is one hell of a writer. His essays are brilliant. Here's a list of pieces he's written for Cracked.com (of which Mr. Wong is an editor), with links:

Five Reasons the Future Will be Ruled By B.S. (http://www.cracked.com/article_18817_5-reasons-future-will-be-ruled-by-b.s..html)
Five Ways Modern Men Are Trained to Hate Women (http://www.cracked.com/article_19785_5-ways-modern-men-are-trained-to-hate-women.html)
Six Moments that Make Video Games Worth It (http://www.cracked.com/blog/6-moments-that-make-video-games-worth-it/)
Was 9/11 an Inside Job? (http://www.cracked.com/article_15740_was-911-inside-job.html)
Five Terrifying Basterdizations of the Wikipedia Model (http://www.cracked.com/article_17341_5-terrifying-bastardizations-wikipedia-model_p2.html)

Also check out this page, which lists all of his work at Cracked.com: http://www.cracked.com/members/David+Wong/

And when I say brilliant, I don't mean sparkler-against-an-overcast-sky brilliant. I'm talking What-would-have-really-happened-if-Tyler-Durden-had-smoked-while-homemaking-explosives brilliant. The essays Wong produces are essentially what yours truly wishes to produce on this little-seen blog: a combination of smart, vulgar wit with deep-cutting analysis. Wong is the best kind of intellectual: the deep thinker who ventures into abstraction, figures something out, and then returns to the dumb/real world and explains his conclusions in language that any ninth grader can understand. Take, for example, 'Five Reasons the Future Will be Ruled By B.S.' Basically, Wong's argument goes like this:

1) In a market, the cost of a commodity is related to the cost of producing it; cheaper production leads to cheaper commodities, and vice versa.
2) Better technology leads to cheaper production of commodities.
3) Our technology has reached the point that producing certain commodities (e.g. e-books) cost of production is virtually nil.
4) You'd think that this would lead to free commodities and wealth for all, a la Star Trek. BUT!...
5) The businesses that make up our economy run on selling stuff for quite a bit more than "virtually nil".
5b) If businesses can't sell stuff, they go out of business.
5c) If lots of businesses go out of business, the economy crashes.
5d) Therefore, businesses need to get us to buy stuff for quite a bit more than it costs to produce it, lest the entire economy crash.
6 and final) Therefore, we need bullshitters (i.e. advertisers) to convince us to buy bullshit we don't need at arbitrarily high prices (i.e. they create artificial scarcity) in order to keep the merry-go-round of the economy spinning. It's fucked up, but there you go.

Wong does a much better job of laying the argument out than I've done here. Now, I'm not saying you have to agree with him (Marxists, for example, are all too thrilled by the prospect of that particular merry-go-round stopping), but the man is a thoughtful, though-provoking, hilarious motherfucker.

Not much of a novelist, though.

Okay, maybe I'm being too hard on him. JDatE is by no means the worst novel ever written: it has a beginning, middle, and climax/resolution (sort of). It has a protagonist, antagonist, sidekick, and love-interest (again, sort of [and actually the love-interest gets switched about a third through the book, like when a TV show fires an actress and replaces her character with another one that's functionally identical but has a different name and hair color]). It has clever dialogue, such as:

"That man, in your, whatever you call it, your communicator. Does he need help?"
"What?"
"He sounds wounded. Does he need your assistance?"
"You're not from around here, are you?"
"Why do you not respond to my questions directly?"
"That's just Fred Durst. On the radio. He's not talking to us."
"Are you certain? It sounds as if he is crying out while someone is strangling him."
"I know. That sound is entertainment to many of us. It's called a 'song.'"
"I know songs. But--I thought they rhymed."

(p.272)

Finally, JDatE does have a plot. Unfortunately, it's presented in such a way that the broad outlines becoming maddeningly obvious early in the story (SPOILER ALERT: evil demons from another dimension are trying to invade our dimension, and the main characters try to stop them by eventually descending into trans-dimensional Hell; plus, there's a lot of dicking around in the middle), while the specifics of the plot are so intricately confused that it becomes waaaaaay too much work to keep track of what's going on (SPOILER ALERT: this specificity-incoherence problem is exacerbated by the fact that the trans-dimensional demons can change history, i.e. what you read about characters doing early in the book doesn't always match what the characters are recalled to have done later in the book, because history changed). This is a big, big problem for a novel: since fictional stories are essentially guided dreams, in which details and specifics are deployed to lull the reader into forgetting that they're reading an obvious lie built of letters on paper, the details need to flow seamlessly into one another. It doesn't matter if the specifics of the story are actually coherent; it only matters that the seem coherent and smooth to the reader. Wong seems unable to pull all his pieces together into a coherent narrative whole. There's so much going on in JDatE--so many long-standing unanswered questions, so many secondary characters, so many AHA! twists and clever reversals--that it's basically impossible to keep track of what's going on. The plot appears as a series of disconnected events: "Now THIS is happening! Now THIS OTHER THING is happening! Now SOME NEW EVENT is occurring!" Characters and objects reappear, and there is a central thread to the story, but it lacks flow. The reader is not so much carried away as they're just awash.

If your plot can't carry the story, then the characters or deep meanings better do it. So far as the latter, JDatE has none that I could find. Sure, it starts out with a narratively-embedded version of the Ship of Theseus, a little story used by philosophers to demonstrate how tricky the concept of identity is. But it doesn't really go anywhere with this ploy: there's just a clever AHA! moment, and then something else happens. And the rest of the novel works in pretty much the same way: some bullshit happens that the reader is sort-of able to follow, while Wong showcases his humor, usually in the form of dialogue, descriptions, and bizarre actions. For example:

I didn't answer, the sound of the commotion dying around me as the heavy monkey of sleep rested its warm, furry ass on my eyelids.

Or:

The group might have either pursued him or raised their rifles to perforate his windshield had a gorilla riding a giant crab not leapt out of the woods and eaten two of them.

It's good stuff. But not enough to carry an entire novel. Nor are the characters up to that particular task: I found myself entirely apathetic as to whether they survived any given debacle (the fact that the protagonist is a bona fide idiot might have something to do with this). Plus they're kind of inconstant: the narrator/protagonist begins the novel as a tight-laced, insecure-but-competent type (like Edward Norton's character in Fight Club), but ends as a sort of socially-incompetent, depressed, barely-repressed-rage guy. The titular John begins as his dopey stoner buddy (like Shaggy from Scooby Doo) and ends as basically Tyler Durden (crude, competent, masculine, successful). The girl, as I've said, goes through two incarnations, both of which alternately fall-for and are-repulsed-by the protagonist, and seem to be there solely for the purpose of providing motivation and a prize to said protagonist (ironically, Wong does a great job criticizing the function of women-as-prizes in fiction, in 'Five Ways Modern Men Are Trained to Hate Women'). And there aren't any other developed characters.

So what I'm saying, in summary, is that the story is a kind of hollow, semi-coherent vehicle for Wong's cleverness and wit. Which cleverness and wit are extensive and impressive, but not enough to carry a novel. Nor do they need to--I repeat, David Wong is a brilliant, dazzling essayist. His articles are what my articles aspire to be. My guess is that he's got a great novel inside of him (no gay innuendo intended, brah), and with some solid editorial guidance, JDatE could have brought all its wacky, clever ideas into a coherent whole. But it didn't. Better luck next time, I guess.


PS: Again, maybe I'm being too hard on JDatE. It's not, like, horrifically bad. It's better than, say, your average serialized sci-fi novel. I guess I'm just disappointed at a novel that, based on Wong's essays, I'd expected to be breathtaking. 

Sunday, December 23, 2012

Daily Bleed for December 23rd, A Radical Anarchist Daybook


Cat Has Had the Time of His Life
thin line

Our Daily Bleed...


The angel was flying through sky in midnight,
& softly he sang in his flight;
& clouds, & stars, & the moon in a throng
Hearkened to that holy song.
He sang of the garden of God's paradise,
Of innocent ghosts in its shade;
He sang of the God, & his vivacious praise
Was glories & unfeigned.
The juvenile soul he carried in arms
For worlds of distress & alarms;
The tune of his charming & heavenly song
Was left in the soul for long.
It roamed on earth many long nights & days,
Filled with a wonderful thirst,
& earth's boring songs could not ever replace
The sounds of heaven it lost.


      — Mikhail Lermontov (1814-1841), "The Angel"




DECEMBER 23 


CHAN K'IN VIEJO 


Last of the Lacandón Mayan t'o'ohil, spiritual leaders.


Oaxa, Mexico: FEAST OF THE RADISHES. 

Aztec logo
Aztec, QUIAHUITL DAY. The protector of day Quiahuitl (Rain) is Tonatiuh. Quiahuitlis a day of relying on the unpredictable fortunes of fate. It is a good day for traveling & learning, a bad day for business & planning.






1597 -- German poet/literary theorist Martin Opitz lives. Remembered for reforming German poetry.



Penis sculpture; source, jargonbooks.com


1617 -- Penal Envy?: First penal colony in North America established in Virginia. Sorry, Bill, that is p-e-n-a-l, not p-e-n-i-s.

'The soul is the prison of the body' 


— Michel Foucault, Discipline & Punish




1761 -- ‘Pickle the Spy’ — Alestair Macdonnell, Scottish Jacobite — dies, pickled in his own juices. 




1804 -- Charles Sailate-Beuve, critic/poet, lives, Boulogne.




1812 -- Help Wanted?: Samuel Smiles lives. Scottish author best known for his didactic work Self-Help, with Illustrations of Character & Conduct. The book is widely translated; one of the first nonliterary books to be translated into Japanese after the Meiji Restoration, a bible for young Japanese men eager to emulate Western ways. 



Poetry Magazine cover


1860 -- Harriet Monroe, founder/longtime editor of Poetry magazine, lives, Chicago, Illinois. 


I am proud only of those days that pass in undivided tenderness. Robert Bly



The American poet was born on this day in 1926.

Robert Bly (born December 23, 1926) is an American poet, author, activist and leader of the mythopoetic men's movement, most famous for his Iron John: A Book About Men (1990), which spent 62 weeks on the The New York Times Best Seller list. For The Light Around the Body he won the 1968 National Book Award for Poetry.

Friday, December 21, 2012

Daily Bleed for December 21st, A Radical Anarchist Daybook




thin line


Our Daily Bleed...

Mary is seven. Homer

Is her favorite author.
. . . She says, “Aren’t those gods
Terrible? All they do is
Fight like those angels in Milton
& play tricks on the poor Greeks
& Trojans. I like Aias
& Odysseus best. They are
Lots better than those silly
Gods.”
fishing while his daughter reads Homer




DECEMBER 21

CARL VAN VECHTEN 


American avant-garde writer, photographer, journalist.




Egyptian




WINTER SOLSTICE (11:12 UTC).



First of the month of Nivose (snowy) in the French revolutionary calendar. 


CHAOS DAY. Eat wontons. 

England: ST. THOMAS' DAY. A Tradition of "Thomasing," begging gifts, door-to-door. 

WICCAN YULE. 

CHINESE FEAST OF WINTER. 

BAD TO THE BONE DAY. 
?


END OF THE MAYAN LONG CYCLE: 13 bactuns, which is 13*144000 days or 5125.26 years (roughly). 

Ahhhhh, the good ol' days! We thought they'd never end.... 






1375 -- Giovanni Boccaccio dies at 62 in Certaldo, Italy.




1549 -- Margaret of Angoulême dies in Odos-Bigorre. Queen consort of Henry II of Navarre, a patron of humanities & religious reformers & an author. Her most important work, Heptaméron, is constructed on the lines of Giovanni Boccaccio's Decameron, (who died on the same day), consisting of 72 tales (out of a planned 100) told by a group of travelers delayed by a flood on their return from a Pyrenean spa. The stories, illustrating the triumphs of virtue, honor, & quick-wittedness, & the frustration of vice & hypocrisy, contain a strong element of satire directed against licentious & grasping monks & clerics.




1620 -- Forefathers' day celebrates landing at Plymouth Rock.

Pilgrims first land at Plymouth Rock. It's not a very big rock, but then they weren't very big Pilgrims. The Mayflower, with a contingent of Puritan separatists from the Church of England, landed at Plymouth, Massachusetts. It had set out 15 September from Plymouth, England; its original destination was Virginia.




1790 -- Source=Robert Braunwart US: Samuel Slater's thread-spinning factory goes into production, Pawtucket, Rhode Island. The beginning of the Industrial Revolution in America. The workers at his machines are 4 to 10 years old.




1799 -- William Wordsworth & his devoted sister, Dorothy, take possession of Dove Cottage at Grasmere, Westmorland.




1804 -- British statesman / novelist, Benjamin Disraeli lives, London. His novels are closely related to his political career which includes two stints as prime minister (1868 & 1874-80).

"Youth is a blunder; manhood a struggle; old age a regret."




1805 -- Manuel Bocage, dies in Lisbon. Portuguese neoclassical lyric poet who dissipated his energies in a stormy life.




1845 -- India: Battle of Ferozeshah takes place, during the first Sikh War.




1858 -- Anthropologist Franz Boas lives, Minden, Germany.




1859 -- Gustave Kahn, French poet/literary theorist who claims inventing vers libre, lives in Metz.




1861 -- US: Schooner Potter arrives at Neah Bay, Washington, bringing annuity goods for the Makah — hoes, sickles, pitchforks, & Mexican spurs — much to the amazement of the fishing & whaling Makah tribe, who converted them to fish hooks, knives, & arrowheads.




1865 -- US: Illegal Executive Order (we know, it's redundant) removes lands from the Oregon Coast Indian Reservation, cutting the territory in half.




1866 -- Source=Robert Braunwart US: Crazy Horse & Sioux Indians defeat US cavalry, Ft. Philip Kearny, Wyoming.



Maud Gonne, source tallgirlshorts.net/marymary


1866 --

MAUD GONNE, Patron Saint 2005-06, 2009-10
Firebrand Irish hermeticist, revolutionist.




1872 -- Phileas Fogg completes around world trip, & wins his wager. So says Jules Verne in a book published in 1873.



1872 -- Shaggy?: American novelist/short-story writer Payson Terhune lives, Newark, New Jersey. Known mainly for his dog stories.



I myself have never been able to find out precisely what feminism is: I only know that people call me a feminist whenever I express sentiments that differentiate me from a doormat. Rebecca West



The author of The Return of the Soldier was born on this day in 1892.

Cicely Isabel Fairfield (21 December 1892 – 15 March 1983), known by her pen name Rebecca West, or Dame Rebecca West, DBE was an English author, journalist, literary critic and travel writer. A prolific, protean author who wrote in many genres, West was committed to feminist and liberal principles and was one of the foremost public intellectuals of the twentieth century. She reviewed books for The Times, the New York Herald Tribune, the Sunday Telegraph, and the New Republic, and she was a correspondent for The Bookman[disambiguation needed]. Her major works include Black Lamb and Grey Falcon (1941), on the history and culture of Yugoslavia; A Train of Powder(1955), her coverage of the Nuremberg trials, published originally in The New Yorker; The Meaning of Treason, laterThe New Meaning of Treason, a study of World War II and Communist traitors; The Return of the Soldier, a modernistWorld War I novel; and the "Aubrey trilogy" of autobiographical novels, The Fountain Overflows, This Real Night, andCousin Rosamund. Time called her "indisputably the world's number one woman writer" in 1947. She was made CBEin 1949, and DBE in 1959, in recognition of her outstanding contributions to British letters.

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Book Review: Free Will, by Sam Harris




Sam Harris is among the "New Atheist" writers whose ranks include Daniel Dennett (Breaking the Spell), Richard Dawkins (The God Delusion), and the late Christopher Hitchens (God is Not Great). Harris' The End of Faith made a splash a couple years after the 9/11 attacks with its arguments against religion in general and Islam in particular: Harris holds faith to be fundamentally irrational, a bizarre and often destructive ritual in which reasoned cognition is suspended. He recently came out with a book on secular ethics titled The Moral Landscape (you can woefully attempt to look at the Harper's review here).

Yours truly was pretty heavily influence by Harris' End, though in the years since I was first caught in the headlights of his polemics, I've come to the opinion that he is very good at forcefully stating obvious truths in such a way that less obvious truths get obscured. For example, End begins with a short narrative of a suicide bombing. Harris describes the bomber, the bus he boards, his victims, and his family's reaction. At the end of this story, Harris points out that in spite of the fact that the narrative does not specify the bomber's religion, the reader is sure to presume him a Muslim. The rhetorical point (I took it) was that Islam really is a violent and dangerous religion, and everyone knows this already; it is only political correctness which keeps us from publicly saying so. In retrospect, I realize that Harris' story was the 21st century equivalent of race-baiting: the narrative didn't expose anything about Islam, but it did expose the way Americans think about Islam. Harris' deployment of an obvious truth ("You're imagining a suicide bomber as a Muslim") obscured subtler truths about e.g. the function of stereotypes in American culture.

The point of the preceding paragraph is just that yours truly is working some personal stuff out vis-a-vis Mr. Harris, who is a compelling and slippery fucker. (Harris also begins Free Will with another little story, this one about a multiple rape/murder--but hey, who can fault a champion of reason for habitually beginning his books with emotionally-charged anecdotes?)

In the tiny tract Free Will, Harris develops one of the claims he made in End: free will is not only false but, indeed, conceptually incoherent.

Free will is an illusion. Our wills are simply not of our own making. Thoughts and intentions emerge from background causes of which we are unaware and over which we exert no conscious control. We do not have the freedom we think we have.

Free will is actually more than an illusion (or less), in that it cannot be made conceptually coherent. Either our wills are determined by prior causes and we are not responsible for them, or they are the product of chance and we are not responsible for them.
(p. 5)

For Harris, saying that someone has free will is like talking about a square-circle. It just doesn't make sense. Our thoughts, "choices," identities, and behavior are all effected by natural causes, just like all other phenomena. There is no extra-causal soul or self which somehow exists outside of, and yet influences, the chains of cause-and-effect which makes up this world. We are caused objects. So how could there be free will? As Harris correctly points out, indeterminism is no help in this: even if, say, quantum indeterminacy means that determinism is false and every new moment is a product of chance, we're no closer to freedom than we were with determinism.

It's important to understand at the outset that Harris is not arguing against any sophisticated version of free will put forth by any philosopher, ever. He is opposed, rather, to commonsense notions of free will:

Our moral intuitions and sense of personal agency are anchored to a felt sense that we are the conscious source of our thoughts and actions. 
(p. 17)

Though Harris spends a good chunk of the book discussing compatibilism (the position that free will and causal-determinism are compatible, held by e.g. Benedict Spinoza and Daniel Dennett), he's not interested in refuting it. His purpose is to convince the reader that the so-called 'free will' which compatibilists are able to preserve is not really free will. It's a fake, like tofu chicken or a knockoff iPod. Harris uses the following comparison:

Imagine that a person claims to have no need to eat food of any kind--rather, he can live on light. From time to time, and Indian yogi will make such a boast, much to the merriment of skeptics. Needless to say, there is no reason to take such claims seriously, no matter how thin the yogi. However, a compatibilist like Dennett could come to the charlatan's defense: The man does live on light--we all do--because when you trace the origins of any food, you arrive at something that depends on photosynthesis. By eating beef, we consume the grass the cow ate, and the grass ate sunlight. So the yogi is no liar after all. But that's not the ability the yogi was advertising, and his actual claim remains dishonest (or delusional). This is the trouble with compatibilism. It solves the problem of "free will" by ignoring it.

Personally, I don't find this comparison very compelling. Dennett's compatibilism may or may not be adequate to the task of reconciling causal determination with human freedom, but it's much subtler than simply 'changing the conversation.' What's especially weird and alarm-bell-ringing about Harris' hostility toward compatibilism is that, later in the book, he begins to sound like a compatibilist. He sometimes writes of "choices" without any scare-quotes, and writes:

Therefore, while it is true to say that a person would have done otherwise if he had chosen to do otherwise, this does not deliver the kind of free will that most people seem to cherish...
(p. 35)

And later still:

Becoming sensitive to the background causes of one's thoughts and feelings can--paradoxically--allow for greater creative control over one's life...This understanding reveals you to be a biochemical puppet of course, but it also allows you to grab hold of one of your strings.
(p. 47)

What in the holy hell is going on here? I thought "Our wills are simply not of our own making"; now you're telling me that "a person would have done otherwise if he had chosen to do otherwise," i.e. he could have done otherwise? And you're telling me that I can gain "greater creative control over [my] life"? You're saying I'm a SELF-PUPPETEERING PUPPET?!?! How the hemorrhaging fuck am I NOT free, then?

In the spirit of cartoonish analogies, I'd like to offer my own: imagine someone said that, given the right equipment, they had the ability of flight--and indeed, with the help of an airplane, they do indeed appear to be flying! However, a non-compatibilist like Harris could criticize the so-called pilot: 'Sure, you seem to be flying, but upon closer investigation we find that what's really going on is just a series of normal physical events. For example, the movement of air across the wings creates upward lift. This is why you appear to be flying; but where is the flight in any of this?'

Harris, in other words, seems committed to rejecting any version of free will which can be coherently integrated into a cause-and-effect schema as not really free will. Intuitively-obvious free will is the only kind that counts. And, I mean, sure: Harris can decide that that's what he means when he talks about "free will," and he's quite correct to say that (that version of) free will is incoherent and non-existent. Correct, but in a trivial way: suppose I say that all maps are two-dimensional, and then you point out that globes are three-dimensional maps, and I say, "Well, they're not really maps. What I mean by 'map' is the commonsense notion of a map." Or as Nietzsche put it:

If I make up the definition of a mammal, and then, after inspecting a camel, declare "look, a mammal' I have indeed brought a truth to light in this way, but it is a truth of limited value.
(From On Truth and Lies in an Extra-Moral Sense)

There aren't any philosophers who take intuitively-obvious free will seriously. For heaven's sake, the entire discipline of psychology amounts to an investigation into the ways in the way's that people's wills are determined by other factors. And while it's true that most of us do use the notion of free will in our daily lives, and also true that a lot of good would come from our society paying more attention to the influences which determine people's behavior, it's not clear to me how writing a snarky, easy-reading philosophy tract is going to encourage anyone who isn't already a philosopher to think more carefully about freedom and causality. If this book is for philosophers, then it's like a fan-fic letter mailed to Jonathan Franzen; if it's for layfolk, then it's like a letter mailed to people who don't read their mail. In any event, why is Harris writing?

One last bone to pick: Harris is deeply inconsistent in his objects of attack. Throughout Free Will, Harris uses other intuitively-obvious notions which are also extremely tricky and problematic when you begin to think carefully about them, yet he concentrates his fire solely on free will and lets other concepts pass unscathed. For example, what do we mean when we talk about "cause?" Is it just reliable correlation? That's what statisticians mean, but that's definitely a watered-down version of what everyone else means by "cause." But what else is there, besides events happening together or not happening together? Or how about "identity": all of the problems Harris poses for free will are at least as problematic to any notion of "me" or "myself." Weirdly, Harris notes in End the problematic, illusory nature of selfhood, yet in Free Will he treats it as a non-issue. Or "object"? What is an "object"? Of course we speak of a physical world with stuff in it, but has anyone ever seen this physical world? Of course not! All we see are our impressions, which supposedly correspond to some 'real world.' And even supposing that there is a real world, what could it possible mean to say that there are different objects in it? It's all just one big whole; distinctions between this table and that tablecloth are illusory and incoherent...Etc.

My point is that there are lots and lots of tricky notions which become mottled and incoherent the moment we begin to think carefully about what they entail. This is not new. Pretty much all of our concepts are problematic. To say that free will has conceptual problems, as Harris does, is not to say that it doesn't exist; and a book concerned with evaluating free will seems obliged to give more consideration to philosophically robust versions of free will than End does.

We were the first store other than the publisher to list #Cypherpunks by Julian #Assange !!


Just listed at LWB: Cypherpunks: Freedom and the Future of the Internet - 19.99 USD http://bit.ly/WlIuqv
Unlike ·  · 

Got some gorgeous holiday/Christmas cards in stock!

Check em out! All from amazing counterculture-y artists. Got em straight from the museum of contemporary art in Los Angeles.



- Posted using my mobile book laboratory.

Two possibilities exist: either we are alone in the Universe or we are not. Both are equally terrifying. Arthur C. Clarke

Sunday, December 16, 2012

Every man is surrounded by a neighborhood of voluntary spies!




The author of Pride and Prejudice was born on this day in 1775.

There are so many to choose from!

One cannot be always laughing at a man without now and then stumbling on something witty.